Disciplinary sanction
Translation generated by AI. Access the original version
First-time submission of medical evidence in the appeal
The Supreme Court (TS) has partially estimated the appeal of a magistrate who was sanctioned by the General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ) with one month of suspension from duties for unjustified and repeated delays in resolving cases. The decision does not mean that the court has ruled out the sanction; what it requires is that some medical and psychological reports that the magistrate submitted upon appealing are studied first. The magistrate submitted those documents when she filed an
appeal , that is, when she requested that the decision be reviewed within the Administration itself. However, the Full Council of the CGPJ confirmed the sanction without assessing its content, because the reports had been submitted at that stage. Later, the affected party went to the TS and requested that without assessing its content, because the reports had been submitted at that stage. Later, the affected party went to the TS and requested that it be they will annul the agreements sanctioning.
The State Attorney defended that the clinical situation did not eliminate the responsibility of the magistrate and that the established facts justified a proportionate sanction. The TS, for its part, considers that the Administration could not reject automatically the evidence presented on time simply for having been submitted in the appeal. It should have examined it if it could influence the assessment of the responsibility.
The court also points out that, in light of the signs of a persistent psychological impairment that could affect the performance of their duties, possible reasonable adjustments and their impact on responsibility and, if applicable, on the sanction should be evaluated. This does not mean that the TS has proven that the medical situation explained the delays.
Therefore, it annuls the agreement of the Plenary of the CGPJ and orders to return to the moment necessary for it to examine the reports, carry out the appropriate checks and issue a new resolution. The TS has not yet decided whether the conduct fit the applied infringement or whether the sanction was proportionate, as those issues depend on the assessment that remains pending.
In claims that may arise from events occurring in the exercise of their professional activity, our lawyers can provide you with appropriate advice and defense of your interests

This website uses both its own and third-party cookies to analyze our services and navigation on our website in order to improve its contents (analytical purposes: measure visits and sources of web traffic). The legal basis is the consent of the user, except in the case of basic cookies, which are essential to navigate this website.